(Photo by Imre Solt via Wikimedia Commons/CC BY-SA 3.0 DEED)

Listen to this article:

The Arabian Peninsula’s harsh geography has long constrained regional development. Despite this, the region’s geographical constraints have been largely overcome by the advent of both oil wealth and modern technology. Following the discovery of oil in the mid-19th century, the region underwent a significant transformation. Over the following decades, urbanization began to reshape the land. Saudi Arabia and Dubai, which were once separate societies, slowly became centrally planned regional powers. 

Currently, Dubai boasts the world’s tallest building and a population of almost 5 million. However, the Gulf’s burgeoning population strains against its limited resources. Ancient groundwater aquifers are no longer able to meet the demand for fresh water, and Dubai’s 66-km coastline is at capacity with luxurious real estate developments. 

The constraints of this densely urbanized and water-scarce region are forcing some Arab Gulf states to undergo a different sort of transformation, one that could become the blueprint for urban sustainability, or could spiral into environmental destruction. 

Defying the Environmental Constraints of the Desert 

The environment of the Arabian Peninsula poses a clear challenge to development. The world’s second-largest desert, the Arabian Desert, nearly encompasses the entire peninsula. Characterized by extreme heat and water scarcity, the region’s ability to reliably maintain resources comes at an environmental cost. 

As no permanent rivers flow through the region, countries are forced to rely on processes of desalination. Specifically, for the UAE, desalination, an energy-intensive process that converts seawater into fresh water, is required to meet most household and industrial water needs. The process leaves a salty brine, which is discharged back into the sea, adding to its electrical usage. This accounts for a significant share of energy use in the Gulf countries. The UAE relies on desalination to meet almost 50% of its water demand. In Kuwait, that value is 90%.

Still, the region’s climate, where temperatures regularly exceed 40 degrees Celsius, continues to strain the electrical sector. During the summer months, air conditioning accounts for 70% of the Gulf’s electricity usage. 

New Frontiers in Developing the Sea

The struggle to overcome geography does not end at the coast. In 2001, the ocean became the next frontier of development as Dubai expanded its tourism sector in a pivot toward diversifying oil revenues. 

The first of these projects, the Palm Islands, comprises three man-made archipelagos constructed from approximately 7 million tonnes of rock and almost 100 million cubic metres of sand. Of the three archipelagos, only one, Palm Jumeirah, is complete. Today, the 5km island has a population of about 25,000 and boasts world-class hotels and resorts. In total, the three developments will add hundreds of kilometres to Dubai’s coastline. 

After Palm Jumeirah, other ambitious land reclamation projects followed. Dubai built The World Islands, an archipelago of 300 islands shaped like a world map. Qatar began construction on The Pearl Island. And Oman began its own land reclamation project, called “The Wave” in 2005. 

Each new development symbolizes the pinnacle of luxury and an attempt at economic diversification, an effort to turn away from reliance on oil revenue. However, sand dredging and land reclamation can smother coral reefs and alter tidal flows. The longevity of these projects has also been called into question following claims in 2011 that the islands were sinking. 

Planning for a Future of Science Fiction 

The latest wave of planned development in the Gulf draws comparisons to science fiction. These projects are astonishingly futuristic and incredibly ambitious. Saudi Arabia’s planned city development, Neom, is envisioned as a high-density and carbon-neutral metropolis. It maintains a solution to Saudi Arabia’s harsh geography and fossil fuel dependence, despite being funded by the continuous export of fossil fuels. 

The proposals for this development include flying taxis, glow-in-the-dark sand, and a regulated climate enabled by weather-modification technology known as cloud seeding. One proposal even suggests a large artificial moon, which could also serve as a projection screen. The smart city is expected to accommodate 9 million people, representing 25% of Saudi Arabia’s population in 2022. 

Neom is just one part of Saudi Arabia’s larger development plan, Vision 2030, an attempt to diversify and reform the country into a beacon of futuristic and sustainable development, where even women can drive flying cars. Similar initiatives, such as the UAE’s Vision 2050 and Qatar’s National Vision 2030, make similar claims about sustainability and energy diversification, presenting these projects as a pivot away from dependence on oil revenues, which largely fund their development. 

Criticism and Greenwashing Allegations

Despite the optimistic framing, some critics warn that these developments are state-sanctioned greenwashing. Indeed, these projects are not beyond reproach. The construction of Neom forcibly displaced about 20,000 people and alarmed UN experts when three members of the Howeitat tribe were sentenced to death after resisting forced eviction. 

According to Saudi Activists, Saudi citizen Abdul Rahim Ahmad Mahmoud al-Hwaiti was shot after refusing to give up their property to make room for the development. Other concerns about the labour conditions of migrant construction workers have arisen after dozens of foreign workers died in horrifying and preventable workplace accidents in both Saudi Arabia and the UAE. Critics warn that Neom’s construction also poses environmental risks like habitat destruction, carbon-intensive construction, and potential interference with regional weather patterns through cloud seeding. 

The Ecological Paradox 

Rather than resource scarcity, places such as Dubai are now well known for their manufactured abundance and opulent displays of wealth. However, much of the technology behind this transformation is a double-edged sword. Solutions provided merely

While desalination produces freshwater to sustain a growing population, it makes seawater saltier. Air conditioning regulates indoor temperature but expels hot air outdoors, increasing outdoor temperatures. Land reclamation projects add beachfront yet strain marine ecosystems. And AI-enabled smart cities require substantial water for cooling computer systems and entail carbon-intensive construction processes. 

The many negative externalities arising from these developments may not affect state or corporate actors. However, the social and environmental costs are borne by migrant workers, Indigenous Bedouin tribes, and sensitive ecosystems. More ironically, all of these diversification projects depend on the very resource they are meant to outgrow. Oil remains the peninsula’s economic lifeline. 

Paths Forward, Roadblocks Ahead

The Gulf’s reinvention is, in part, a testament to human ingenuity. The transformation from inhospitable desert to thriving metropolis is no small accomplishment. However, as each development exceeds Earth’s natural limits, a new set of ecological challenges emerges. 

As infrastructure becomes more efficient, consumption, demand, and development increase. Whether the Gulf states can successfully pivot away from their foundational dependence on oil and into a sustainable tech utopia remains to be seen. But there is another dependence at play, one even more human than reliance on fossil fuels: the need to keep expanding, regardless of the cost.

Edited by Isaac Code